Keyword tools label intent from patterns in the string, not from what Google actually rewards. The obvious approach - trusting the tool's "commercial" or "informational" tag - fails because Google has already decided the answer and shows it in the result types. If eight of ten results are category pages, a blog post will not rank there no matter how good it is.
WHEN TO REACH FOR THIS
Use when you have a keyword list and need to decide what kind of page, if any, can actually rank for each term.
read-intent-from-live-serps.md
---
name: read-intent-from-live-serps
description: Use when you have a keyword list and need to decide what kind of page, if any, can actually rank for each term.
---
# Read Intent From The Live SERP
Keyword tools label intent from patterns in the string, not from what Google actually rewards. The obvious approach - trusting the tool's "commercial" or "informational" tag - fails because Google has already decided the answer and shows it in the result types. If eight of ten results are category pages, a blog post will not rank there no matter how good it is.
## What you need first
- a shortlist of candidate queries
- a clean or incognito browser set to the target country
- a note of the page types you are able to produce
## Method
1. Search each query in an incognito window with the location set to your target market, not your office location, because local intent shifts result types entirely.
2. Count the top ten by page type: product, category, comparison, forum, tool, news, editorial. The majority type is the format Google will accept from you.
3. Record which SERP features are present - shopping carousel, People Also Ask, video pack, local pack. A shopping carousel above the fold means organic clicks are already thin.
4. Look for mixed SERPs where no type holds more than five slots. Those are unresolved intent and are the cheapest entries because Google is still testing formats.
5. Check the age and depth of the weakest three results. If any is a thin forum thread or a 2019 listicle, that slot is winnable; if the weakest result is still a well maintained brand page, deprioritise.
6. Tag every query with the required page type and drop any query whose required type you cannot or will not produce.
## What this produces
A keyword list where every term carries a required page type and a winnable or not-winnable verdict based on observed results.
## Where this goes wrong
- Judging the SERP while logged in and personalised, which hides the real result mix.
- Assuming a keyword with a forum result is easy - Reddit and Quora rankings are often the hardest to displace because Google is rewarding the discussion format, not the domain.
- Treating a Featured Snippet as a win target when the query has no click-through left underneath it.
---
From the QuQi skill library - https://www.quqi.io/skills/read-intent-from-live-serps
Free to download · no account, no email
A keyword list where every term carries a required page type and a winnable or not-winnable verdict based on observed results.